The State (on application by Madalitso Fred Kazombo) v Malawi Electoral Commission

Malawi case

Court: High Court of Malawi
Registry: Civil Division
Bench: Honourable Justice Violet Palikena-Chipao
Cause Number: Judicial Review Cause No. 61 of 2025
Date of Judgment: September 22, 2025

Headnotes

  1. Civil Procedure – Judicial Review – Application for leave – Application dismissed due to procedural errors and deficiencies in drafting. 

Summary

Download

The Applicant sought leave from the High Court to commence judicial review proceedings against the Malawi Electoral Commission regarding an election. The Court reviewed the application and its supporting documents and identified numerous irregularities, including typographical errors, wrong citations, and unclear arguments, concluding they were prepared in a hurry. Due to these procedural deficiencies, the Court dismissed the application. The Applicant was granted liberty to refile a properly drafted application, with the directive that any new proceedings for leave must be made with notice to the Respondent.

Statute and Subsidiary Legislation Construed

Download

N/A

Ruling/Judgment

Download

1. The Applicant, Mr. Madalitso Fred Kazombo has petitioned this court seeking permission to commence judicial review proceedings against the Malawi Electoral Commission in respect of its decision in relation to the just conducted election whose results we are still waiting. The application for leave is made pursuant to Order 19 rule 20, 21 and 22 as read with rule 13 and 19 of the Courts (High Court) (Civil Procedure) Rules, 2017 (hereinafter the CPR).


2. Upon going through the application, sworn statement verifying grounds for judicial review and the skeleton arguments in support of the application, the court noted a number of irregularities or errors in the manner in which the documents were prepared including typos, wrong citations of provisions in some respects, unclear arguments and compounding of facts among others. It would appear the application was done in a hurry and without proof such that in some respects, it is difficult to appreciate what Counsel intended to communicate to the court.


3. In this regard, the application cannot be granted. It is dismissed with liberty to refile a properly drafted application and supporting documents if the Applicant so wishes. If the Applicant decides to refile the judicial review proceedings, the application for leave should be made with notice to the Respondent.


4. It is so ordered.


Made in Chambers on 22nd day of September, 2025

Related Cases

Explore similar cases that share the same legal category, court, or judge. These cases may provide additional context and precedents relevant to this matter.

Commercial Cause Number 259 of 2019

Prima Fuels Limited and Another v Total Malawi Limited and Another Commercial Cause Number 259 of 2019

The 1st Claimant applied to the High Court (Commercial Division) to strike out the 1st Defendant’s notice of appeal or to vacate the order for stay of...

High Court of Malawi
Honourable Justice Trouble Kalua
View Full Case Details
Election Case No. 12 of 2025
Sep 23, 2925

David P Banda v The Attorney General (Malawi Electoral Commission)

 The Claimant applied to the High Court for an interlocutory injunction to prevent the Malawi Electoral Commission from announcing election results fo...

High Court of Malawi
Honourable Justice S.A. Kalembera
View Full Case Details
Election Petition No. 54 OF 2025
Nov 07, 2025

Francis Renso v Malawi Electoral Commission & Walter Nyamirandu Manda

cooking

High Court of Malawi
Honourable Justice Mandala D. Mambulasa
View Full Case Details
Commercial Cause Number 181 of 2025
Nov 06, 2025

Chiyembekezo Missi t/a Good Hope General Dealers v George Macheka and Rachael Fatchi

The 1st Defendant sought an order from the High Court, Commercial Division, to suspend the enforcement of a default judgment entered against him on 15...

High Court of Malawi
Honourable Justice Trouble Kalua
View Full Case Details
Commercial Cause Number 162 of 2025
Nov 05, 2025

Mehmet Salih Bayrakday v Mohammed Abdul Mennan

The Claimant applied for summary judgment in the High Court of Malawi, Commercial Division, against the Defendant for the payment of $110,000.00. The...

High Court of Malawi
Honourable Justice Trouble Kalua
View Full Case Details
Civil Cause Number 162 of 2023
Oct 28, 2025

AC (A Minor) acting through Litigation Guardian Mr CJ v Mr Jenala Solomon and 4 Others

The Claimant sought declarations and damages in the High Court, Principal Registry, against the healthcare provider, his employer, the government mini...

High Court of Malawi
Justice M.A. Tembo
View Full Case Details